Bethlehem Presbyterian Church, founded by the Rev. Martin Post in 1841, is Cass County’s congregation of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A). It is located at 5588 State Road 25, Logansport, Indiana, in Bethlehem Township.
Bethlehem’s former pastor is the Rev. Theda McBryde. Pastor Theda grew up in DeMotte, Indiana, and was schooled at Calvin College and Western Theological Seminary. Before coming to Bethlehem, she was a hospice chaplain in Kalamazoo, Michigan. She and her husband, Malcolm, moved to Detroit, Michigan, in June of 2021. Currently Bethlehem does not have an installed pastor.